Jimmy's HideAway

100% love it
P-town's hidden gem
Offering their special blend of "comfort tavern food," Jimmy's Hideaway is a hole-in-the-wall eatery serving surprisingly delicate dishes.


    • Wiltonian
      Wiltonian Over a year ago
      Loves it

      Totally Superb
      We only found it through the GayCities iPhone app, cause it really is kinda hidden. On the bayside of Commercial Street (the mostly non-sidewalk side), you only see a painted sign. It marks a short alleyway, to some steps down to a French-door entrance. Inside is a modest-sized but lovely restaurant, with great food and service. There really is a Jimmy, whom we met, and his partner Ray. We liked it so much we went there 2 nights in a row, breaking our usual rule of trying a different place each night while on vacation. We figured it was unlikely we'd find another place we'd like as much. Plus the owners are gay and on the premises, the staff is excellent, the prices reasonable for the quality of dishes, the atmosphere very warm & cozy, not blatantly touristy. We couldn't ask for anything more. Definitely on our list for our next P-Town trip.

    • upstagr
      upstagr Over a year ago
      Loves it

      Hidden Gem
      This was recommended by a mutual friend of the owner and I'm so glad he did because we would've missed it. Simply, the food was terrific. This is an absolute must stop. My partner and I actually went there a few times while we were in P-town.